Traditional vs Progressive Schools

Do you have kids who need to take the exam to big school this year? You guys might want to read this first... I attended a talk by Didi Manahan, a professor at the Ateneo and the directress of Explorations Preschool and Keys Gradeschool about traditional and progressive schools. I think it is important to realize that progressive schools are present nowadays because there is more and more proof that people learn differently. And just because one doesn't go to a traditional school, it doesn't mean that he/she is "intellectually challenged". As a quick overview, these are the basic differences between a traditional and a progressive school.

 

 

You might be thinking that, hey, progressive doesn't seem so strange after all. In fact, if you've visited the school that our son went to, and listen to their philosophy, you will definitely think it makes MORE sense to send your child to a progressive school! What with 40 children per class in a traditional school??? How will your kid learn at all?

One thing that really draws me to a progressive curriculum is that the concepts are investigated upon. The kids aren't made to swallow things "just because". I think that that's what is needed now--to teach kids how to be critical thinkers.

However, for those who are not convinced, here is the list of pros for traditional schools.

 

 

Something to think about, parents. PS--and if you're wondering about us, well, Paul's going to his dad's school. =p We'll see how he fares. His dad promised me we'd assess and discuss this after Grade 1 or 2. We'll see...abangan ang susunod na kabanata.

March 10, 2009 UPDATE! Please consider using our School Reviews feature to leave and / or look for opinions on schools. Thank you!! - admin

Comments

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

any progressive school near SM Fairview

...my 7-yr old son changes school every year for the past 4 years. i was looking for 'something' in a school and just soooo tired i may find it until i stumbled on this site, thanks to mom exchange.
would appreciate very much if you could possibly refer to me any progressive schools near SM Fairview.
super thanks!!!

banwah's picture

PROGRESSIVE EDUCATION (Singapore Maths/Science)

Would any parents be interested to enrol their kids for Progressive Maths / Science Tutorial?
We also have Progressise Seminal onto Singapore Maths / Sc for parents / guardians who would like to have a better idea onto it.
Conducted by trained school teacher from Singapore itself.
If so, please contact us at either 4673216, 09178013545 or banwah@singnet.com.sg

Anonymous's picture

Pre Schools in Mandaluyong

Hi! My daughter is turning 3 this May. Appreciate feedback on good schools in Mandaluyong. Thanks!

Mom-Friday's picture

pre-schools in mandaluyong

Explorations Pre-school on Araullo st. is one of the best I have checked out, they have 2 morning sessions and 1 afternoon session. I already reserved a slot for my daughter, also 3 y.o. TLC on Pilar St. is also a very good school, with 2 morning sessions. Yu Ming on Ideal st. is another one with very good reviews as well. Location of these 3 schools are all near (Puregold) Shaw Blvd.
Hope this helps.

Anonymous's picture

preschool

There are a lot of pre schools around mandaluyong check out: Alphabet House 7220018 Maam Rita. your daughter will be in good hands...

Anonymous's picture

List of traditional or progressive schools in QC

My son is 5 years old and has been attending Nursery in a school near our place. He has been diagnosed with delayed speech but has been improving each day. He might have special needs but has been proven to adapt to a regular classroom. My husband and I plan to look for another school this year.

Any suggestions on traditional or progressive schools in QC? Thanks!

Mom-Friday's picture

List of trad or progressive schools in QC

hi, i highly recommend DML Montessori pre-school on 7th st. New Manila. It is a traditional school with Montessori application. My son is diagnosed with mild sensory processing disorder but can go to regular schools with small class size. He is now Prep in DML and he loves it there so much. The school is run by Catholic nuns and are very supportive of students with special needs. They accept anyone and don't discriminate. They offer Nursery, Kinder and Prep, students are 2 to 6 years old. You can call the directress, Sr. Nives Porlares at 7224979. Other schools in QC like The Nest and Child's Place also received good reviews.

Anonymous's picture

OB Montessori

hi..i plan to enroll my kids at ob montessori, both are pre-school ( 4yrs and 6yrs old) any feedbacks would definetly help my in my descision, plus does anyone here knows how much is enrollment there?

Anonymous's picture

i really need to know..

hi..any feedbacks about creative learning., humpy dumpy..,casa instruccion de montessori..and mulberry..all in kapitolyo pasig..or maybe u can recommend me a best progressive school near to this place..i really really need your suggestions..thanks a lot..:)

Anonymous's picture

i need your help..

im having a problem looking for a best progressive school for my 5 yr. old girl and 3yr.old son...near kapitolyo, pasig..i need your suggestion guys..it will be a great help..thanks..

jencct's picture

St Rafael St

Hi I recall that a friend has a school on St Rafael St. Her name is Joanne Jesena. The school's name...I vaguely remember as St Rafael Learning Center (but I'm not sure). Hope this helps.

Jen

Anonymous's picture

Update on Good Progressive School in Caloocan or Quezon City Are

Hi,

Was looking for an alternative school for my kid near the Caloocan Grace Park area when I stumbled upon this thread. Read some of the post and it seems that "Early Achievers Learning Center" at Sgt Rivera, QC, is not so good an option anymore. Does anyone have a review of a school named Pace Academy also along Sgt Rivera?

Are there other schools in the Caloocan Grace Park area that anyone can recommend? Preferably w/ Chinese lessons and progressive style. If not Chinese at least Progressive style of teaching?

Thanks in Advance.

Anonymous's picture

hi there, i'm also from

hi there,

i'm also from caloocan area, as far as i know, there is no progressive style of teaching in that area, nearest would be meridian, it's around in mother ignacia, qc area, progressive daw ang teaching dun accdg. from a friend, i think they have chinese class too.

Anonymous's picture

chinese school in cal / qc

i would suggest grace christian high school. it's not progressive, though. it still uses the traditional method, but it's a really good school and they teach chinese. :)

Anonymous's picture

Hi Admin, I checked the

Hi Admin,

I checked the school reviews first but couldn't see reviews for Pace and ratings for other schools in the area, hope its ok if I posted my inquiry here. Sorry if I broke any rules, you may delete my post if I did so. Thanks.

pia.inductivo's picture

Better Preschool in Project 3 Quezon City

Hi' i'm new here, just want to know, what is the best preschool (progressive) in Project 3 Q.C.? Anyone?

pcvf17's picture

John Dewey School for Children/ QC

I'm also from QC. My kids are enrolled in John Dewey for almost 3 years already and I could proudly say that every penny paid is worth it!

You can contact them at 9220020. Look for Teacher Rochelle Razo.

Best Regards,

Mommy Portia Frando-Dauz

The Bridge School's Open House

For parents hunting for a school...

The school my son attends... The Bridge School... is holding their Open Houses in January and February.

For incoming Younger Preschool (kids 3.6-4.5 years old), it's gonna be held this Saturday, Jan 9, 930am, and for incoming Older Preschool (kids 4.6-5.5 years old) it'll be on Saturday, Jan 16, 930am.

For more info, check out their website, www.thebridgeschool.ph

jpfabs's picture

pre-schools in frvw/commonwealth

Hi moms! Do you recommend any schools in fairview/commonwealth area? My 3 y/o kid will be studying next SY 2010. Help! :D Thanks!

august10's picture

REACH International School

Hi everyone! Do you have any feedback about "REACH International School"? Thanks a million!

Anonymous's picture

Hi! My 8 year old is on his

Hi! My 8 year old is on his 3rd year at REACH next school year and my 6 year old will be moving there next school year, too. It's a progressive, totally non-traditional school that banks on individual education and the child's personal pace. They have great social activities to balance off the one-on-one curriculum. I like it because my boy catches up without peer pressure. He's self-motivated. But like I said, this is no way the same as the conventional school set-up. Some parents like it, some don't. Check it out. REACH gives trial classes.

august10's picture

Reach IS

May I know how much is the tuition fee in REACH? Thanks a million!

garlic's picture

traditional vs. progressive schools

Hi mommies I'm a newbie here and have been reading your posts for two days now.
I've been seriously thinking about transferring my two kids, aged 6 and 3 to a progressive school next schoolyear. They're both enrolled in a Chinese traditional school this year. (Btw, the school claimed to be part traditional part progressive when I asked them about their curriculum before, but it turns out, upon observation that they're not really progressive but traditional).

I live in Sta. Cruz and I'm having a hard time looking for a good progressive school near our place. Two of my friends are suggesting COLF or the Community of Learners Foundation in VAlencia Q.C. , Waldorf in Heroes Hill or OB Montessori.

Kindly help me by posting your insights on these three schools konti lang kasi ang narinig ko about them and if you have any idea regarding the tuition fees please please help me.

thanks and more power to moms exchange!

Anonymous's picture

COLF

We have heard good things about the quality of education at COLF. According to our sources, their kids are learning without the stress. Tuition fee is around 60K. Based on recommendations, we visited the school and noticed that the children are independent, speak good english, seem confident, etc. My children enjoyed the way the teachers conduct the lesson [the prospective new students are allowed to sit-in the class]. However, we're hoping that the school will consider the improvement and proper maintenance of the classrooms, canteen, restrooms and all the other facilites of the school.

cute_alala's picture

Re: Traditional vs Progressive Schools

Any mommy living in Pasig area? Do you know the Parkwood Playschool in Legaspi Ave., Maybunga, Pasig City? Is it a good school? thanks!

Anonymous's picture

Re: Re: Traditional vs Progressive Schools

hi! my son and daughter studied at parkwoodplayschool.i guarantee you its a very good progressive school.My children are very good in communicatng their ideas and they are able to analyze things beyond what I expect of them. My son is now grade 1 and my daughter is about to graduate now.

Anonymous's picture

Re: Traditional vs Progressive Schools

looking for a pre-school or
learning center in global,city

Anonymous's picture

Reggio Emilia schools

Hi!

I'm a mom with a 2year old daughter. I've been searching the web for preschools using the Reggio Emilia approach but I have been unsuccessful. Do you know of any schools (preferably within Paranaque and Alabang) that teach the Reggio Emilia approach?

Thanks!
Michelle

Anonymous's picture

Reggio Emilia School

Hi, I wonder what is Reggio Emilia Method is? Tnx.

emsa0723's picture

Colegio San Agustin Makati

Hi there! Any feedback on Colegio San Agustin Makati. I want to enroll my son there for kinder... thanks

banwah's picture

Registered?

Had you registered your son there?
I feel that the school is ok.

Anonymous's picture

Learning tree preschool

Any mommies have feedback on the Learning Tree Preschool in Cubao, Quezon City?

fizzy1's picture

The Learning Tree

TLT is a wonderful preschool, using a progressive developmental approach. My son has had 3 wonder-filled happy years there. It is child-centered, the teachers are great and highly competent (many graduated from UP FLCD), the facilities are ok (lots of learning materials & space to move around), the curriculum responds to preschoolers' developmental needs (academic, emotional, social, physical, etc.), and learning is not limited to the classrooms. Go and visit the school and you will see active, confident, happy children: for them, school is fun, fun, fun!! Their graduates easily get into (even excel in) 'big' traditional schools, but for The Learning Tree, that is not what is important: it is nurturing your child's full potentials. And isnt that what we want at this crucial stage of our children's lives?

Anonymous's picture

Re: The Learning Tree

Thanks fizzy1. The TLT preschool in Cubao is far from our place, but we are strongly considering TLT Sikatuna for grade school.

Anonymous's picture

cambridge

any feedback on cambridge pre-school? its a singaporean school.

banwah's picture

Great!

But, does it really follows all the Singapore syllabus?

Anonymous's picture

Would appreciate feedback re COLF

Hi! I'm pretty new to Mom Exchange, but I've been checking this blog out regularly for the past month. (Thank you so much for having this forum, by the way.) I wanted to ask if there are any of you out there who can give me feedback re Community of Learners Foundation (COLF). See, my son's graduating from Kinder this year, and I'm looking for a progressive gradeschool for him. The irony is, I actually teach in a very large traditional school. But, after years of teaching in this school, years of going through undergrad and MA in education, and, most importantly, knowing my son, I've decided that I would rather expose my boy to progressive education. We live in the QC area, so I've been trawling the web looking through progressive schools. So far, I've been really looking at COLF, but I wanted the parents' perspective. Hope someone can help me out. Thanks!
rinna's picture

Re: Traditional vs Progressive Schools

I think I remember reading an article by Panjee Tapales (who sends her kids to Waldorf) about how the school doesn't really encourage reading until age 8 or 9 and her son actually learned how to read at that age. I think in the more mainstream approach, we all would've started to panic and enrolled our child in Kumon or any one of those intensive tutorial places if that happened to us. But according to her, it never really hampered her son's love of reading and her son is a voracious reader. So in the grand scheme of reading, does it really matter if the child was able to read at 3 vs 9? Would I rather have a 3yr old who can read but does not really like/love reading? Or someone who learned how to read late but looooves reading? I'd choose the latter. IMO, progressive schools have somewhat different philosophies and priorities. We cannot expect children in progressive schools to develop at exactly the same pace as children in traditional schools. And vice versa. As the article above suggested, it is a matter of right fit for the child. Some would flourish in progressive schools and others would do better in traditional schools. We have to get to know our children and their learning styles too and not just go with what we(parents) want.
Anonymous's picture

Re: Re: Traditional vs Progressive Schools

Your observations make a lot of sense to me because these put emphasis on our responsibilities as parents, and not on how we exercise our prerogatives. I hope you don't mind my standing on your shoulders for a moment and saying that if we add the third option of home-schooling, it conveys the kind of conviction we parents should have, once we have chosen among the three--be it traditional, progressive or home schooling. Our child attends a progressive school and I still can only imagine the kind of doubts that home-schooling parents have to endure while still standing as educators to their offspring. I've met some very successful parent-teachers and their child-students and I have to say that they are impressive to the point of actually being intimidating. There will always be debate, some of it even healthy. But at the end of the day, the parent's choice of schooling is a promise that he/she will have to make good on, EVERY DAY, until graduation. :)
rinna's picture

think long term

well, I think when deciding on progressive vs traditional, one has to think long-term. If you're thinking, yeah, we'll do progressive schools for elementary and then send them to traditional schools for highschool, then I think it will somehow follow that in some aspects, the kids may not be "up to par" with whatever standards these traditional high schools have and will take some amount of adjusting to this new approach to learning.
Anonymous's picture

Re: think long term

An excellent point! Wish I had thought of it :)
Anonymous's picture

Hhmmm...

This thread is heating up. I just wished parents would try to calm down and be more mature about what has been written. I live in Pasig and I don't even know the school but am getting quite a good as well as bad idea of how it's parents are --- and maybe how the school is too.
Anonymous's picture

Of Hot Words and Offended Parents

I noticed that too! Things seem to heat up when people make sweeping statements about the KIDS in the schools. Like this one parent who said "If you want your child to be laid back, take him to that school. But if you want your child to be an achiever, scout for other schools." Then the thread really heated up! Not surprising since I think that unhappy person went way out bounds and already offended the parents, and belittled the kids, at that particular school. Maybe, you would like to see things in this context, and not to judge too quickly the parents or the school that, on the surface, seems to be the cause of their argument. I mean, we wouldn't want to commit the same mistake that this unhappy parent made. Would we?
Anonymous's picture

Re: Of Hot Words and Offended Parents

I see your point. I found that "unhappy parent's" comment and read it very carefully. As a parent, I also would have reacted very strongly! The schools are what we are reviewing as fellow parents. But this person was so angry at the school that he over stepped and finished his comment with an attack on the kids and their parents. Thank you for bringing this up.
Anonymous's picture

please, not cradle of joy, or any other small grade school!!!

WHEN MY BOY WENT TO CRADLE OF JOY, i thought they will be able to teach my child the basics of elementary education. lo and behold, my kid did not even pass 1st year! the high school told us my child needs to go to grade 7 bec he was not taught the basics...!!! this is my advice, any "big" school with gradeschool but not a small school with gradeschool. they will not be able to teach the minimal requirement of gradeschool. little did i know, his classmates had to go through grade 7 in another school because of the same problem!!!
Anonymous's picture

regrets in RAYA

I brought my daughter in Raya School and I regret bringing her there. There is no structured curriculum yet. I have been warned by my friends, then, that I should think twice before enrolling my child in new schools because curriculum would be experimental. When my child took the entrance test in another school, the child psychologist who administered the exam told us that our child's technical side is superior but only average on the other aspect. According to the examiner, that would be attributed to her former's school lack of training on reading comprehension. If you want your child to be laid back, take him to RAYA. But if you want your child to be an achiever, scout for other schools.
Anonymous's picture

regrets at Little Apprentice

That sounds exactly like our experience at the Little Apprentice in Alabang. So much concentration on play but no structure nor concentration on the technical aspects....That was relayed to me by the guidance councilor at De La Salle Zobel. I now found a good pre school called Cradle to Crayons in Marcelo Green Village. It's a small school but I swear, the education that my daugher is getting is comparable to none...and the few weeks that she's been in school, she's showed a distinct improvement in all aspects. She's more disciplined and her joy for learning is now so evident. No more calls from the teachers that our daughter wants to go home.... Teachers don't have to be Harvard trained to be considered good....trust me, our daughter's previous teacher was Harvard trained for all the good it did for us....
Anonymous's picture

looking for a chinese progressive preschool

hi everyone! i just joined this site and i'm learning a lot from all of you. i just want to ask if you guys can suggest a chinese progressive preschool in qc. we live near cubao. our daughter just turned 2 and we're scouting a school for her for next year. many thanks! :)
Mom-Friday's picture

looking for a chinese progressive preschool

hi, there are very few chinese progressive schools, but you can try St. Marks near E.Rod, i think they are more traditional but good feedback from parents. The Learning Connection (TLC) in Pilar st. Addition Hills, Mand. is a progressive school where I will enroll my daughter. There's also Yu Ming. DML Montessori in 7th st. New Manila has weekly Chinese lessons.

Anonymous's picture

RE: Looking for chinese progressive school

Hi there,

You may try Meridian School or John Dewey School for Children at Quezon City. They are offering mandarin subjects for kids.

Thanks.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly. If you have a Gravatar account, used to display your avatar.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options